Carmen Victoria St George

Judge Carmen Victoria St George currently presides in Court of Claims in Suffolk County and has served as a New York judge for 9 years.

Judge St George was most recently appointed to the bench by a New York Governor for a term beginning in 2017 and ending in 2023.

To view Judge St George’s profile on the New York State Courts website, click here.

Judicial metrics

Click to expand sections for an explantion of each metric

Publication Rate: 15.8 decisions per year

Higher than 99.23% of judges in the dataset

Public Discipline: 0 determinations

Higher than 0% of judges in the dataset

Suppression Reversal Rate

Not applicable: judge absent from dataset

Excessive Sentence Findings

Not applicable: judge absent from dataset

Excessive Sentence Reductions

Not applicable: judge absent from dataset

Reassigned Reversals

Not applicable: judge absent from dataset

Favored Commercial Bonds

Not applicable: judge absent from dataset

Blocked Affordable Bail

Not applicable: judge absent from dataset

Disproportionate Carcerality

Not applicable: judge absent from dataset

Published Decisions

126 decisions

2024

Gewanter v. State of New York

View
2022

Matter of Roche v. New York State Div. of Human Rights

View
2021

Croce v. St. Joseph's Coll. N.Y.

View
2021

Thiele v. Town of Southampton Zoning Bd. of Appeals

View
2020

Minerva v. County of Suffolk

View
2020

Executive Fliteways, Inc. v. Murta

View
2020

Matter of Legal Aid Socy. of Suffolk County (Indeed Inc.)

View
2020

Oberlander v. Wolf

View
2019

Matter of Ford v. Board of Educ. of the City Sch. Dist. of the City of N.Y.

View
2019

Matter of Lafontaine v. Board of Educ. of the City Sch. Dist. of the City of N.Y.

View

NYSCEF Decisions (Unpublished, E-Filed Decisions)

102 decisions

2023

Maddock v. Stanza

View
2022

Mann v. Holder

View
2022

Szilagy v. Town of Smithtown

View
2022

Maddock v. Haines

View
2022

Maddock v. Haines

View
2021

Brillante v. Mid Is. Physical Therapy, PLLC

View
2021

Sumner v. "John Doe"

View
2021

Maddock v. Haines

View
2021

Petraglia v. County of Suffolk

View
2021

Hunko v. Argueta

View

Last updated June 15, 2025. Produced by Marc Lajoie and Oded Oren.
©2025 Scrutinize. All rights reserved.