Alexander R. Renzi

Profile data snapshot: February 19, 2026 Details may have changed since.

As of February 19, 2026, Judge Alexander R. Renzi presides in the Supreme Court of Monroe County, having served on the bench for 37 years. Judge Renzi was most recently elected to the bench for a term beginning in 2024 and ending in 2028.

Judicial metrics

Click to expand sections for an explantion of each metric

Publication Rate: 0.1 decisions per year

Higher than 46.67% of judges in the dataset

1 published decision over 13 years

Suppression Reversal Rate: 9.0%

Higher than 84.1% of judges in the dataset

7 suppression reversals out of 78 suppression-related appeals

Excessive Sentence Findings: 1 cases

Higher than 86.38% of judges in the dataset

Excessive Sentence Reductions: 4 years

Higher than 88.62% of judges in the dataset

Reassigned Reversals: 1 cases

Higher than 97.54% of judges in the dataset

Public Discipline: 0 determinations

Higher than 0% of judges in the dataset

Favored Commercial Bonds

Not applicable: judge absent from dataset

Blocked Affordable Bail

Not applicable: judge absent from dataset

Disproportionate Carcerality

Not applicable: judge absent from dataset

Published Decisions

1 decision

2017

People v. R.P.

View

Suppression Reversals

7 decisions

2025

People v. Alcaraz-Ubiles

View
2025

People v. Surles

View
2023

People v. Ocasio

View
2021

People v. Hughes

View
2015

People v. Wilcox

View
2012

People v. Lee

View
2011

People v. Ayers

View

Excessive Sentences

1 decision

2021

People v. Zdatny

View

Reassigned Reversals

1 decision

2024

People v. Mack (2024)

View

[Judge's] statement, 'there's no way in God's earth that if you're convicted of this crime you're going to get towards the minimum with me[]' 'amounted to...impermissble coercion [to plea]'.

NYSCEF Decisions

1 decision (not counted in Publication Rate calculations)

2014

People v. Smith

View